![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Israel will harvest a future of violence and conflict with Lebanon George E. Bisharat, San Francisco Chronicle, Jul 20, 2006 This article was originally published by the San Francisco Chronicle and is republished with the author's permission. To interview George E. Bisharat contact the IMEU at 510-451-2600 or info@imeu.net
Now, strolling along shaded pathways with my kids, overlooking the intense blue of the Mediterranean Sea, and breathing the pine and jasmine-scented air, I recalled my year there before Lebanon's ruinous civil war. I pointed out the banyan tree under which I sat gathering signatures for a petition on some passionately contested issue of university governance. I showed them the classrooms where we debated social theory, the wall I vaulted to get back to my dormitory after university gates were closed for the night. I chuckled while my seventeen-year old nephew gaped at gorgeous, stylishly dressed Lebanese women students. My daughter seemed equally impressed by Lebanese men. Beirut of eleven days ago was a city of growing, yet still guarded confidence. The endearing traits of the people - hospitality, entrepreneurial ambition, and conviviality - were as much in evidence as when I first arrived over thirty years ago. The most acute physical and psycho-social wounds of the fifteen-year civil war no longer festered, although some of the factors that had led to it - socio-economic disparities, a political system that entrenches sectarian identity and power, weak central government, and subsequent vulnerability to the meddling of external powers - had never been fully resolved. Yet people took obvious pride in the reconstruction of their city and society, and were looking forward to the future.
Little did we realize, as we departed for home through the gleaming halls of Beirut's new airport, boarding what turned out to be one of the last flights out - that within days, as Israeli Chief of Staff Dan Halutz put it, Lebanon's clock would be "turned back twenty years." Hundreds of millions of dollars of investment, and untold ingenuity and effort, have been blown to rubble in Israel's outburst of violence. The airport, highways, bridges, the port, gas stations, power stations, even the proud modern lighthouse on Beirut's coastal promenade - all have been devastated in Israel's lethal tantrum. No one in Beirut believes that Israel's primary objective is to free its captured soldiers. Israel still holds Lebanese prisoners it abducted years ago, and could have negotiated an exchange, as it has done in the past. Indeed, Israel initiated hostage taking in Lebanon, kidnapping non-combatant Hizbullah leaders in 1989 and 1994. As recently as 2004, Israel and Hizbullah reached an agreement, brokered by Germany, for the exchange of prisoners and the remains of fallen soldiers. No, my friends say, watching Israeli jets streak over Beirut to deliver their deadly payload, Israeli military pride is at stake. Humiliated when Hizbullah drove it out of Lebanon in 2000, after a brutal occupation of eighteen years, and stunned again by the recent Hizbullah and Hamas raids, the Israeli army is exacting revenge. It further hopes that a rain of death and destruction will turn the Lebanese people against Hizbullah, and pressure the Lebanese government to confront the stubborn resistance organization. Yet Israel will harvest the future of conflict and violence it has sewn, facing foes of ever-increasing sophistication and determination. Some Lebanese may resent being dragged into a firestorm by Hizbullah. But they know who their real tormentor is, and who has thwarted their country's march toward peace and prosperity. Lebanese and other Arabs also know the American origins of the weaponry Israel uses to kill their children and smash their homes. They will remember the US veto of a balanced UN Security Council Resolution that would have helped stanch the bleeding in their country. They will hear President Bush's statement that Israel "has a right to defend herself", a functional green light for the carnage they now face. I hope it is not another stretch of years of insecurity that again keeps me from Beirut. When I return, I hope I can look my Lebanese friends in the eye, and explain to them why my country stood by while theirs was destroyed. George E. Bisharat is a professor of law at Hastings College of the Law in San Francisco, and writes frequently on law and politics in the Middle East.
Home > News & Analysis > Analysis > Israel will harvest a future of violence and conflict with Lebanon |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||